Constructive Neutral Evolution- Evo Desperation at its Finest
-
Constructive neutral evolution. Total bullshit. this is supposed to happen when you have proteins diffusing around the cell, they bump into other proteins and just happen to form something. And if that something is useful it gets added and kept. This can go on to include several proteins (yeah, right).
However that is only a one-off thingy. There isn't any heritability there. Any offspring will also have to go through the SAME CNE to get that same protein configuration.
Larry Moran does a decent write-up for this- constructive neutral evolution
CNE is nothing but another atheistic "Hail Mary pass". Too bad it doesn't have a prayer.
I would love to know how evos plan on testing this idea- my guess is they are going to try to make any opponents disprove it.
Constructive neutral evolution. Total bullshit. this is supposed to happen when you have proteins diffusing around the cell, they bump into other proteins and just happen to form something. And if that something is useful it gets added and kept. This can go on to include several proteins (yeah, right).
However that is only a one-off thingy. There isn't any heritability there. Any offspring will also have to go through the SAME CNE to get that same protein configuration.
Larry Moran does a decent write-up for this- constructive neutral evolution
Imagine an enzyme "A" that catalyzes a biochemical reaction as a single polypeptide chain. This enzyme binds protein "B" by accident in one particular species. That is, there is an interaction between A and B through fortuitous mutations on the surface of the two proteins. (Such interactions are common as confirmed by protein interaction databases.) The new heterodimer (two different subunits) doesn't affect the activity of enzyme A. Since this interaction is neutral with respect to survival and reproduction, it could spread through the population by chance.How could it spread through the population? It isn't a heritable change. Contingent serendipity is not passed down. It has to be renewed.
CNE is nothing but another atheistic "Hail Mary pass". Too bad it doesn't have a prayer.
I would love to know how evos plan on testing this idea- my guess is they are going to try to make any opponents disprove it.
Ultimately, scientific ideas must not only be testable, but must actually be tested — preferably with many different lines of evidence by many different people. This characteristic is at the heart of all science. from Testability and science
Evos are getting very, very desperate. And it shows.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home