"The privileged planet argument isn't that great."-Rich Hughes
So Rich Hughes sez that the priveleged planet argument isn't that great-
1- It is better than anything Rich's position has to offer
2- I doubt that Rich understands argument put forth in "The Privileged Planet"- ya see it contains real science which is over Rich's head.
However I could be wrong- so here is Rich's- or anyone elses- chance-
1- Present a better argument that supports your position
2- Demonstrate an understanding of the argument in "The Privileged Planet"