On The NON-Circularity of CSI
Intelligent Design's opponents are so willfully ignorant and scientifically illiterate it is pathetic. Now they are saying that CSI (Complex Specified Information) is a circular argument. However reality refutes that claim as CSI exists REGARDLESS of what caused it.
The argument for intelligent design via CSI is that every time we have observed CSI and knew the cause it has always been via some intelligent agency- ALWAYS. And there has never been an observed instance of nature, operating freely, producing CSI- NEVER. Enter science- science takes that as whenever we observe CSI and don't know the cause we can safely scientifically infer it was via some intelligent agency.
So where is this alleged circularity? Obviously it is only in the minds of our willfully ignorant and scientifically illiterate opposition.
ETA: ID's opponents are so lame they don't even understand what "nature, operating freely" means. Wow, just wow.